Evidence Preservation

Dram Shop Evidence Preservation Checklist

The records that decide an alcohol service case are often the first to disappear. Surveillance systems overwrite, point-of-sale data rolls off, and staff move on. This checklist lists what to identify and preserve early, who usually controls it, and how to log each request.

By Ryan Dahlstrom

Dram Shop Expert Witness | Last Updated: November 2026

Confirm the Basics Before Sending Requests

Before drafting a preservation letter, pin down the facts that define what needs to be kept:

  • The incident date, the venue name and address, and the licensee of record on the state liquor license
  • The window of time the patron was on the premises, from arrival to departure, plus a margin before and after
  • Every location the patron may have been served, including other bars, an earlier event, or a hotel
  • Who operates the venue day to day, including any management company, promoter, or outside security contractor
  • Which systems the venue uses for point of sale, payments, surveillance, ID scanning, reservations, and scheduling

Records That Disappear First

  • Surveillance video. Many systems overwrite automatically, sometimes within days. Request native exports for entrances, bar wells, service stations, seating areas, VIP sections, the parking lot, and exits for the full time window, along with the camera map and the player software needed to view the files.
  • Point-of-sale audit trail. Item-level checks with open and close times, server and terminal IDs, voids, comps, discounts, transfers between tabs, reopened checks, and manager overrides. The audit log often shows changes made after the fact that a printed receipt does not.
  • ID scanner data. Scan logs record who was admitted and when, and some systems keep only a rolling history.
  • Payment processor records. Card authorizations and tip adjustments held by the processor, which can confirm purchases when venue records are incomplete.
  • Third-party platforms. Reservation, guest list, bottle service, ticketing, and rideshare records held outside the venue.
  • Radio and phone logs. Security radio recordings, manager phone logs, and group text threads among staff on the night of the incident.

Staffing, Service, and Policy Records

  • Schedules, time clock punches, station or section assignments, and the manager on duty for each shift
  • Shift notes, manager logs, and end-of-night reports
  • Written alcohol service policies in effect on the incident date, including drink limits, refusal-of-service procedures, and escalation steps
  • Promotions running that night, such as drink specials, open bars, bottle packages, or all-you-can-drink offers
  • Door counts, occupancy logs, and clicker records
  • Pour specifications, recipes, and drink menus showing standard portion sizes

Training and Supervision Records

  • State server certification records for every employee who served the patron, with issue and expiration dates
  • In-house training materials, sign-in sheets, and completion records
  • Signed policy acknowledgments, including alcohol service and refusal-of-service policies
  • Coaching, discipline, and termination records related to alcohol service
  • Manager and security training records

The Server Training File Checklist lists what a complete training file contains.

Incident, Security, and Outside Records

  • Incident reports, security logs, ejection and refusal logs, and banned-patron lists
  • Prior incident history at the premises, including police calls for service
  • Police reports, crash reports, EMS run sheets, and hospital records, obtained through the proper process
  • State liquor agency licensing file, inspection history, and prior violations
  • Social media posts by the venue, promoters, or patrons from that night

Log Every Request

For each category, record the custodian, the system or location of the record, the date range requested, the date the request was sent, the response deadline, the date records were received, the format produced, and any gap or missing interval. Keep original files and their metadata, work from copies, and note any record the venue reports was overwritten or never kept.

The Alcohol Service Record Review Worksheet includes a Records Received tab for this log.

Sample Preservation Language Counsel Can Adapt

Please preserve all records relating to the service of alcohol to [patron] on [date] at [venue], including without limitation all surveillance video for the premises from [time] through [time] in native format, the complete point-of-sale audit trail including voids, comps, transfers, and manager overrides, ID scanner logs, payment processor records, staff schedules and time records, training and certification records for all employees on duty, written alcohol service policies in effect on that date, incident and security reports, and all communications among staff concerning the patron or the incident.

Counsel should tailor this language to the jurisdiction and the facts of the matter.

Download the Dram Shop Evidence Preservation Checklist

Enter your name, email, and firm below and the file will download immediately. Every item on this page is also available to read above at no cost.

This resource is educational and does not provide legal advice. Counsel determines preservation obligations, applicable law, and case strategy in each matter.

Frequently Asked Questions

What evidence should be preserved first in a dram shop case?

Surveillance video, the point-of-sale audit trail, and ID scanner data, because these systems commonly overwrite or purge records automatically. Preservation requests should go out as soon as the venue and time window are known.

Why does the point-of-sale audit log matter if receipts are available?

A printed receipt shows the final state of a check. The audit log shows each item as it was rung in, along with voids, comps, transfers, and reopened checks, which can show service that a receipt alone does not.

What policies should be requested from the venue?

The written alcohol service policies in effect on the incident date, including drink limits, refusal-of-service procedures, escalation to a manager, and any promotions running that night, along with signed employee acknowledgments of those policies.

Does Ryan Dahlstrom help counsel decide which records to request?

Yes. Discovery consultation is part of the engagement scope, including which records to request and which operational questions to raise with venue witnesses.

Related Resources

Request Expert Consultation

Attorneys may request a curriculum vitae, fee schedule, and case consultation. Expert witness services are available to assist attorneys in analyzing alcohol service practices and dram shop liability issues.

Ryan Dahlstrom, dram shop and liquor liability expert witness

Ryan Dahlstrom – Dram Shop Expert Witness

Ryan Dahlstrom is an expert witness with over 35 years of hands-on experience in the hospitality and entertainment industries. He has managed and advised bars, restaurants, nightclubs, and multi-unit operations across the United States, and he specializes in cases involving dram shop liability, negligent security, and responsible alcohol service practices.

Ryan has been retained by both plaintiff and defense attorneys nationwide to provide expert opinions, deposition testimony, and courtroom analysis in complex alcohol-related cases. His deep understanding of state dram shop statutes, Safe Harbor protections, intoxication timeline analysis, and security standards makes him a trusted authority in litigation involving overservice, intoxication, and venue liability.